Self-Directed IRA Prohibited Transaction Costs Taxpayers Over $250K

The latest IRA prohibited transaction case is called Peek & Fleck v. Commissioner, U.S. Tax Court 140 T.C. No. 12 (March 8, 2013) and concerns two tax payers who used self directed IRAs to establish and fund a newly formed corporation which corporation purchased a fire and safety company that was for sale by third parties and was known as ASF Company.

Infographic: how a personal guarantee on a loan for a self-directed IRA investment became a prohibited transaction in Peek and Fleck v. Commissioner, and how to avoid it
Infographic: how a personal guarantee on a loan for a self-directed IRA investment became a prohibited transaction in Peek and Fleck v. Commissioner, and how to avoid it

The Personal Guarantee Mistake

Both Mr. Peek and Mr. Fleck funded the newly formed company with funds from their self directed IRAs and the company used those combined funds in the approximate amount of $400,000, as well as a bank loan for $450,000, and a loan from the sellers of the business of $200,000 to acquire all of the stock of ASF Company. In entering into the $200,000 loan with the sellers, however, Mr. Peek and Mr. Fleck (who were not personally invested or owners in the transaction) signed personal guarantees and offered their personal residences as collateral as part of the terms of the loan with the sellers. This critical mistake, the personal extension of credit for their IRAs investment, resulted in the IRS alleging a prohibited transaction under IRC § 4975 (c)(1)(B).

The Tax Court Sides with the IRS

The Tax Court agreed with the position of the IRS and disqualified the IRAs investment all the way back to when the prohibited transaction and the personal extension of credit for the IRAs occurred. This was extremely problematic for the self directed IRA owners as they were later able to turn their IRAs $200,000 investment into a return of over $1,500,000. However, the consequence of the prohibited transaction negated the IRAs tax favored status and resulted in the self directed IRA owners incurring taxes of over $250,000 per account owner. Using self directed IRAs in the investment was an excellent idea, however, the actions of using personal credit to solely benefit the IRAs clearly violated the prohibited transaction rules and literally cost the self directed IRA owners hundreds of thousands of dollars.

How to Avoid This Mistake

An alternative way to approach this issue would have been to avoid the personal guarantees and use of the IRA owner’s personal assets as collateral and to instead structure the loans used to purchase the business as non-recourse loans perhaps being secured in favor of the sellers by the stock being sold. An additional alternative may have been to include other non-disqualified persons whose IRAs were not invested and to include them as partners and as possible personal guarantors to the loans.

KEY TAKEAWAY

As a general rule of thumb, always avoid signing personal guarantees or offering personal assets as collateral when obtaining loans to fund self directed IRA investments. Seek out what are known as non-recourse loans where you do not have to offer your personal name or assets as collateral and you’ll keep your IRAs tax preferred status outside of scrutiny by the IRS.

THE SELF-DIRECTED IRA HANDBOOK

Mat’s best-selling guide to the rules: prohibited transactions, UBIT, IRA/LLCs, and the mistakes to avoid.

Get the Free Handbook

Prefer to talk it through? Book a call with a Directed IRA specialist

Mat Sorensen

Mat has been at the forefront of the self-directed IRA industry since 2006. He is the CEO of Directed IRA & Directed Trust Company where they handle all types of self-directed accounts (IRAs, Roth IRAs, HSAs, Coverdell ESA, Solo Ks, and Custodial Accounts) which are typically invested into real estate, private company/private equity, IRA/LLCs, notes, precious metals, and cryptocurrency. Mat is also a partner at KKOS Lawyers and serves clients nationwide from its Phoenix, AZ office.

He is published regularly on retirement, tax, and business topics, and is a VIP Contributor at Entrepreneur.com. Mat is the best-selling author of the most widely used book in the self-directed IRA industry, The Self-Directed IRA Handbook: An Authoritative Guide for Self-Directed Retirement Plan Investors and Their Advisors.

Performing Due Diligence Before You Invest & The Due Diligence Top 10 List

Before you invest your hard earned savings or your self directed IRA into a “non-traditional” business or real estate investment of another you need to ask some hard questions to the person or business receiving your money. Here are some tips to keep you out of legal trouble and to help you avoid bad investments or structures.

Infographic: the due diligence top 10 list, red flags that mean do not invest and the checks to always make before a non-traditional investment
Infographic: the due diligence top 10 list, red flags that mean do not invest and the checks to always make before a non-traditional investment

The Due Diligence Top 10 List

  1. 1If you don’t understand how the business or investment makes the returns being promised, then don’t invest.
  2. 2If you aren’t given adequate documents outlining what has been explained to you verbally or what has been put into a presentation then don’t invest.
  3. 3If you’re told that you can get a commission for bringing others to invest into the same company and if you don’t have a license to receive such commissions then don’t invest. If the investment sponsor is willing to violate the law to pay an un-licensed person to raise money from others then what’s stopping them from misappropriating your money you invested? It is only the law preventing them, which they’ve proved they will disregard.
  4. 4If you are loaning money for a real estate venture, then demand a deed of trust or mortgage on title to the property protecting your investment. Also, make sure that you get a copy of the title report or commitment showing what position your loan is being placed into when the deed of trust or mortgage is recorded. Many savvy investors (and what all banks do) create lending instructions to the title company closing the real estate transaction and tell the title company to only use the funds being loaned when the borrower signs the note/loan documents, when the title company verifies the priority of the deed of trust you are getting (1st position, 2nd, etc.), and whether all other defects to title have been cleared (and if not cleared, disclosure of what they are).
  5. 5If you’re investing into a PPM or private offering you should receive lots of documents outlining the investment, the use of funds, the background of those managing the company, and also documents regarding your rights as an investor (e.g. offering memorandum and LLC operating agreement or LP limited partnership agreement). Also, check to see if the PPM or private offering was properly filed with the SEC by going to SEC.gov and checking the company name in the SEC database. If no filing record exists for the PPM or private offering with the SEC then the person raising the funds has possibly disregarded the law. As stated earlier, if someone is willing to disregard the law to get your money what is stopping them from disregarding the law to not pay you back (it’s just the law)?
  6. 6Investigate the background of the person you are entrusting your money with. When you are investing with others you need to think like the bank and do what the bank does. What is this person’s credit worthiness? What is their employment or prior business experience? What is their business or investment plan? What are the terms of the investment? Is there a realistic rate of return that fairly recognizes the risk being taken?
  7. 7If you are pressured that this opportunity will pass if you don’t invest now, then let the opportunity pass. Most scams use this technique and most legitimate investments never have this funding crisis.
  8. 8Make sure a lawyer representing your interests reviews the documents. If a lawyer drafted the documents already it is still important to have a lawyer look at the documents as they relate to your interests and with an eye towards protecting you. Sometimes, unfortunately, the devil is in the details and many investments have clauses that can significantly impact your ability to get your money back out or that give the company raising the money the ability to pay whatever compensation to themselves they desire. These are obvious problems that will eat into the bottom line of the profits you may be expecting.
  9. 9Seek the opinion of another investor, business owner, or friend whose opinion you trust. Sometimes, when you explain the investment to someone else they can help you find issues to consider and questions you should be asking.
  10. 10Be comfortable saying no and only invest what you are willing to lose. Non-traditional investments have made many millionaires over the years but they have also caused lots of financial ruin. Just keep the risk in perspective and don’t “bet the farm” in one deal.

Don’t be scared about investing into non-traditional investments. Just remember though that you may need to get out of your comfort zone by asking lots of questions, by demanding additional documentation, or by simply saying no. Remember, you are the best person to protect yourself. So do it.

THE SELF-DIRECTED IRA HANDBOOK

Mat’s best-selling guide to the rules: prohibited transactions, UBIT, IRA/LLCs, and the mistakes to avoid.

Get the Free Handbook

Prefer to talk it through? Book a call with a Directed IRA specialist

Utilizing Multiple LLCs & A New Series LLC State

Last year Kansas became the ninth state to adopt a Series LLC statute and their law is now in full effect. A Series LLC allows a real estate investor with multiple properties to increase their asset protection by minimizing their liabilities between properties.  But before we explain how Series LLCs work and the states where it is available it is helpful to first explain how many properties you should hold in a regular LLC.

Infographic: one LLC versus separate LLCs for rental properties, when separate LLCs make sense, and how a series LLC works
Infographic: one LLC versus separate LLCs for rental properties, when separate LLCs make sense, and how a series LLC works

Why Investors Use Multiple LLCs

Most real estate investors use a limited liability company (“LLC”) to hold their properties as the LLC protects the owner of the LLC from the liabilities of the business/property. In other words, if something goes wrong on a property the tenant/plaintiff is forced to sue the LLC and cannot sue the owner of the LLC personally or get at the LLC owner’s personal assets. However, the plaintiff in a suit against an LLC is able to go after the assets of the LLC, which would include the property and anything else in the LLC. So, if you have multiple properties in one LLC the plaintiff can go after all properties. In order to avoid this liability situation investors can separate out the properties among multiple LLCs so that if something goes wrong in one property that liability is contained in the LLC that holds only that property and the other properties held in their own separate LLCs are outside the reach of the plaintiff. The benefit to multiple LLCs is that you can have separate liability protection for each property but the downside is that you have additional costs in setting up and maintaining additional LLCs.

When Separate LLCs Make Sense

When determining whether to put multiple properties in one LLC or whether to put separate properties into their own LLC the primary issue is how much equity is between the properties because the equity in the properties is what is being protected in a multiple LLC scenario. As a general rule we typically advise clients to use multiple LLCs when they have $200,000 in equity between properties in an LLC (or will have with a new property).  At this level of equity there is enough value to protect between the properties to outweigh the cost of the new LLC set up. If there is only $10,000 in equity between multiple properties in an LLC, because each property is fully mortgaged, then there is less equity to protect and we wouldn’t recommend separate LLCs for asset protection purposes. Additional factors to consider in determining whether to establish multiple LLCs for your properties are the type of properties (e.g. multi-family would be more in need versus single family) and the location of the properties.

How a Series LLC Works

In nine states as well as the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico, a real estate investor can set up what is called a series LLC. A series LLC provides for what are called sub-series and each sub-series (essentially its own LLC) holds its own property and gets separate liability protection. This is all accomplished in one Series LLC filing to the state and then one tax return for the series LLC but allows for an unlimited amount of sub series and as a result allows real estate investors to have each property they own treated separately for asset protection purposes. So, for example, a series LLC owner would own one property in Series 1 of ABC Investments, LLC, a series LLC, and then Series 1 would own one property. If something happens on the property in Series 1 then the liability is contained there and Series 2, 3, 4, 5 etc. cannot be attached or otherwise subject to the liability of Series 1.

States With Series LLC Statutes

The Nine states with a true Series LLC statute are; Delaware, Iowa, Nevada, Utah, Illinois, Oklahoma, Texas, Tennessee, and now Kansas.

WATCH OUT

I should note that Minnesota, Wisconsin, and North Dakota offer an LLC called a Series LLC but it is confusingly different from what I have described as a Series LLC as these states only allow for different interests of ownership of the LLC but don’t allow for separate treatment of each series for assets and liabilities. Be wary in these three states when creating a Series LLC, as it may not be what you are expecting.

Keep in mind that the Series LLC structure only works when you have properties in the states that recognize Series LLCs. For those with properties in states without a Series LLC statute, we recommend the traditional multiple LLC structure described above to obtain the increased asset protection amongst multiple properties. For assistance in analyzing whether your asset protection structure would benefit from multiple LLCs or a Series LLC please contact the Law Firm.

S-Corp Salary/Dividend Split and Reasonable Compensation

One of the most common tax minimization strategies used by operational small business owners is known as the salary/dividend or salary/net income split. This strategy can only be properly executed in an s-corporation where a business owner can pay themselves a portion of income in salary and a portion of income in dividend or net profit. The ultimate goal is to pay as little salary as possible (and therefore as much net income as possible) so as to minimize the amount of self employment taxes that are due.

Infographic: how the S-corp salary and net income split works, what the court did in Watson v. Commissioner, and four factors for setting a reasonable salary
Infographic: how the S-corp salary and net income split works, what the court did in Watson v. Commissioner, and four factors for setting a reasonable salary

Where the Strategy Works

This strategy cannot be utilized in a c-corporation nor can it be utilized in an LLC or sole proprietorship. It is only possible in an s-corporation as similar income running through a sole proprietorship or an LLC is entirely subject to self employment tax as income cannot be split between salary and net income in an LLC or sole proprietorship. Also, keep in mind that such a strategy is not utilized in passive business structures such as real estate businesses as rental income, interest income, and other passive income is exempt from self employment tax and therefore it is not necessary to implement the income splitting technique of the s-corporation.

How the Income Split Saves Tax

In short, the strategy is implemented by “splitting” the income that is payable to the s-corporation owner into two categories: salary and net income (aka dividend). The reason this splitting of income is advantageous is that net income received by the s-corporation owner is not subject to the 15.3% self employment tax that is otherwise due and payable on salary. For every $10,000 of income an s-corporation owner can classify as net income as opposed to salary the business owner will save $1,530. Keep in mind that after about $100,000 of salary the savings of pushing additional income to net income is reduced as the self employment tax rate drops to 2.9%. It is still certainly worth implementing at higher income but the savings are then made at the 2.9% rate.

Watson v. Commissioner

When this strategy was first utilized many years ago, some taxpayers decided to just pay all of their income out as net income and elected to take no salary or wages and therefore pay no self employment tax. This was quickly challenged by the IRS and Revenue Ruling 59-221 was issued which stated that a business owner who renders services to their business must take “reasonable compensation” for the services rendered.  Over the years, the Courts have ruled on many cases of what is reasonable compensation but in 2012 the Courts made a significant ruling where they adjusted a business owner’s allocation between salary and net income in a case known as Watson v. Commissioner, 668 F.3d 1008 (8th Cir, 2012).

EXAMPLE

In Watson, the owner/employee Watson was a CPA and took $24,000 of salary a year and about $190,000 of annual net income. The IRS challenged the allocation of $24,000 of salary as being unreasonably too low. Watson lost in the District Court and appealed to the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals who re-characterized Watson’s income to $93,000 of salary and about $120,000 of net income. The case is an important one for properly understanding the factors that should be considered in all businesses when determining how much income a business owner can claim as net income instead of salary.  Here are some of those factors.

Factors Determining Net Income

  • ✓Professional services businesses should take a larger portion of salary to net income than those in non-professional services: If the business is a professional services business (e.g. physician, dentist, lawyer, consultant, real estate broker, contractor, etc.) the IRS will more carefully scrutinize the services provided by business owners because the business provides a personal service.
  • ✓Full-time working business owners should take a larger portion of salary to net income than part-time working business owners: If the business owner is involved full time in the business, more salary will be required. If the business owner’s involvement is part time or if they are involved in other businesses, a much lower salary can be justified.
  • ✓Don’t take a salary that is below the salary paid to lower level employees in the business: In the Watson case the Court determined that a salary for Watson of $24,000 was not reasonable as new accountants’ salaries at his office were more than this.
  • ✓Take a salary that is around the industry average for a person of similar experience in your industry: In the Watson case the Court scrutinized the experience and training of Watson and determined that a salary of $24,000 was not reasonable as accountants with similar experience and training in the industry were paid at least $70,000.

In summary, the salary/net income split is a legitimate tax planning technique for business owners but it is not one in which a business owner making over $200,000 a year can justify taking about 10% of income as salary (as was the case in Watson).  The Court disallowed the 10% salary level but did allow him to take about 43% of his income as salary (and almost 60% as net income). This still resulted in some excellent tax savings.

As a general rule, we recommend that business owners take at least 1/3 of their income as salary and pay self employment tax on those amounts. Many other factors should be considered, such as those outlined above, and every business has a unique situation. The good news is that taking a large portion of income from a business as net income as opposed to salary is alive and valid and there are plenty of taxes to be saved each year by using this strategy. A business owner just can’t get too aggressive and take salary levels that are grossly below what people with similar experience in the industry are paid.

How to Have a $20 Million IRA like Mitt Romney? Self Direct It And Invest in What You Know.

The Wall Street Journal reported on January 19th that former Massachusetts Governor and Presidential candidate Mitt Romney has an IRA valued between $20 million and $100 million dollars. The article speculates about how those earnings were made and eventually concluded that because there is no way he could have such significant returns in mutual funds or typical stock or bonds that he must have invested in companies that he was consulting and working with while running the private equity firm he founded called Bain Capital. In other words, he self directed his retirement account into investments with small companies that he knew.

Infographic: two lessons from Mitt Romney’s IRA, self-direct beyond mutual funds and invest in what you know, plus common self-directed options and typically prohibited investments
Infographic: two lessons from Mitt Romney’s IRA, self-direct beyond mutual funds and invest in what you know, plus common self-directed options and typically prohibited investments

Two Lessons From Mitt Romney’s IRA

There are two important lessons to be learned from Mitt Romney’s $20 Million IRA. First, you don’t have to settle for a select group of mutual funds when investing your retirement plan and you can self direct it into all kinds of investments allowed by law including small companies such as Gov. Romney. Other popular self directed options are real estate, or loans, or precious metals. A Romney campaign aide who was questioned about Romney’s investments answered that the tax treatment for Romney’s IRA “is the same for Gov. Romney as it is for every citizen of the U.S.”  This is true. Don’t feel trapped into investing your IRA or other retirement plan into the menu you get from your account custodian. Look to put your retirement account with a self directed retirement plan custodian who will allow you to invest in any investment allowed by law. Typical prohibited investments by law include collectibles, life insurance, s-corporation stock, and related family member transactions and others outlined in IRC 4975. All else is fair game.

The second lesson to be learned is that Gov. Romney’s IRA account success was a result of him investing in what he knew. Many of our clients express frustration in their retirement plan investments because they end up investing in mutual funds, bonds, or stocks that they have no idea how they will turn out and have no skill or insight that gives them an advantage in their investments. However, many of our clients who self direct their retirement plans have found success in investing their retirement plans into what they know. This could be real estate or a small start-up company. Keep your investment portfolio open to self directed retirement plan options and don’t feel trapped into the typical stocks, bonds and mutual funds. As with all investments, please consult with competent legal professionals before investing money. There are scams and bad deals out there and you need to make sure your retirement account is properly protected before you invest.

In sum, the rules for self directed retirement plan investing can be tricky but with the proper counsel and with good investment decisions you can be well on your way to a $20 Million IRA. If you’d like a referral to a self directed retirement account custodian or if you have questions about self directing your retirement account, then please book a call with Directed IRA.

FREE SELF-DIRECTED IRA GUIDE

Learn how to invest your IRA in real estate, private companies, notes, precious metals, and more.

Get the Free Self-Directed IRA Guide

Prefer to talk it through? Book a call with a Directed IRA specialist

LLC Versus Umbrella Policy

Many real estate investors and landlords often ask whether they should use an umbrella insurance policy or an LLC to protect them from liabilities that may arise on their rental property. An LLC protects the owner of the LLC from liabilities that arise on any property in the LLC and prevents a plaintiff from being able to go after the LLC owner personally. As a result, we often say that an LLC protects a business owner’s personal assets from the risks and liabilities of the LLC business. An umbrella policy is coverage above and beyond the typical property insurance and covers additional risks and adds additional coverage to a typical property insurance policy.

Infographic: how an LLC and an umbrella policy each protect a landlord, the factors to weigh, and when to consider both
Infographic: how an LLC and an umbrella policy each protect a landlord, the factors to weigh, and when to consider both

Issues and Factors

There are many issues and factors to consider in making this decision and there is no one-size-fits-all recommendation. In many instances we recommend that you have both an LLC and an umbrella policy and in other instances we may recommend just an LLC or just an umbrella policy.

Cost and Coverage

The first factor to consider is the cost. Beyond the up-front cost to set up an LLC, on average you can expect about $200 in fees a year to keep that LLC active with the State (about $900 annually in California, each state is different). As a result, the major cost of an LLC is in the first year but you can plan on having about $200 in fees each year (each state is different) to keep your LLC active. If you have a partnership LLC then you also have the cost of an LLC partnership tax return but the LLC also provides a significant amount of partnership advantages and protections.

An umbrella policy on the other hand is typically paid for monthly.

EXAMPLE

Let’s say you are able to get $1M in umbrella protection at a cost of $50 a month. That would run you about $600 a year.

$1M

in umbrella protection

$50

a month

$600

a year

Insurance policies have benefits which include attorneys whom the insurance company will appoint and pay to defend you (and protect themselves from having to pay) but also contain certain exclusions to coverage that may leave you with no coverage for the liability you incur.

Type of Property

Another important factor to consider is the type of property you own. If you own a multi-unit property or commercial property we would recommend having both an LLC and an umbrella policy because you have more liability exposure when you have more tenants. On the other hand, if you have a single family rental in an otherwise good neighborhood where you feel less likely to be sued then we may only recommend an LLC or an umbrella policy on its own.

Bottom line, consider both an LLC and an umbrella policy in your analysis and get quotes and advice upon which to make an informed decision so that you are protecting your assets in the most efficient and effective way as possible.