Roth Conversion Mistakes That Could Wreck Your Retirement Plan

Roth conversions are one of the most frequently recommended strategies in retirement planning, and for good reason. I appreciate their benefits for a variety of reasons, but they’re not suitable for everyone.

In this article, I’ll cover eight common scenarios where a Roth conversion may actually not make sense. These are not obscure or unusual situations; they’re real-world examples I see regularly in practice.

The challenge is that Roth conversions have been oversimplified into the idea that you should always convert. In reality, this approach ignores important factors such as current and future tax rates, timing, retirement income planning, and even your age. Getting a conversion right can create tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars in long-term savings. Doing it wrong can have the opposite effect.

Infographic: 8 times a Roth conversion may not make sense
Infographic: 8 times a Roth conversion may not make sense

The Core Principle: It’s a Tax Rate Arbitrage Decision

Before diving into specific scenarios, it’s important to understand the core principle behind a Roth conversion. When you convert traditional IRA funds to a Roth, you pay taxes today so that future withdrawals are tax-free.

At first glance, it may seem straightforward: convert now if your current tax rate is lower than what you expect to pay later. For example, imagine you’re 50 years old with a $100,000 traditional IRA and currently fall into the 10% tax bracket. Converting that balance today would trigger a $10,000 tax bill.

Now picture that same IRA ten years later—worth $200,000 when you’re 60 years old and in a 20% tax bracket. If you withdraw in retirement instead of converting earlier, you’d owe $40,000 in taxes. In this example, converting at the lower rate would clearly have been the smarter move.

When Converting Wins: Lower Rate Today
Convert at 50 Withdraw at 60
IRA value $100,000 $200,000
Tax bracket 10% 20%
Tax owed $10,000 $40,000
Simplified illustration. Converting early saves $30,000 in this example.

However, the reality for many investors is the opposite. Most people are in a higher tax bracket during their working years than they will be in retirement. Because of this, Roth conversions can easily become more expensive than beneficial. That’s why it’s essential to evaluate your current versus future tax brackets before deciding if a conversion truly makes sense.

Scenario #1: You’re in a Higher Tax Bracket Today Than You Will Be Later

Let’s look at a common scenario where a Roth conversion can actually backfire. This happens when you’re in a higher tax bracket today than you’ll be later in retirement.

Imagine you’re 55 years old, earning $250,000 per year, and in the 32% tax bracket. If you convert a $100,000 traditional IRA to a Roth right now, you’ll owe $32,000 in taxes immediately.

Now suppose you don’t convert. You let the account grow for 10 years, and by age 65, it has doubled to $200,000. At that point, your retirement income is around $100,000, placing you in a 12% tax bracket. When you begin taking withdrawals, you’ll pay $24,000 in taxes (12% of $200,000), which is far less than the $32,000 you would have paid in your high-earning years.

Convert at 55 vs. Withdraw at 65
Convert now (age 55) Wait and withdraw (age 65)
IRA value $100,000 $200,000
Tax bracket 32% 12%
Tax owed $32,000 $24,000
Waiting saves $8,000 in tax here, even though the account is twice as large.

This is a very typical scenario for people in their peak earning years who consider converting while their tax bracket is highest. Ten years later, when they’re retired and earning less, their tax rate is lower, making the earlier conversion costlier than necessary.

Key takeaway: A Roth conversion typically isn’t advisable when your expected retirement tax rate will be lower than what you pay today. There are exceptions, such as when you expect only a modest drop, for example 32% to 22%. If the difference is substantial, like 32% down to 12%, converting could be a mistake. Always run the numbers and compare what your tax burden would be today versus in retirement before making the decision.

Scenario #2: You Don’t Have Enough Income or Assets for It to Matter

This scenario doesn’t get discussed nearly enough, but for many middle-income households, a Roth conversion often doesn’t move the needle at all.

Consider this example: you retire with a $150,000 traditional IRA and have about $40,000–$60,000 in annual retirement income. In this situation, you may owe little to no income tax when taking IRA distributions. In effect, your traditional IRA can behave much like a Roth, thanks to the deductions available to seniors.

For instance, once you’re 65 or older, you can claim the standard deduction of $32,200, the additional senior deduction of $3,300, and potentially the new senior deduction from the One Big Beautiful Bill of $12,000 (for married couples filing jointly). That’s roughly $47,500 in total deductions. This means your first $47,500 of retirement income is tax-free, and income above that is taxed at only about 10–12%.

2026 Deductions: Married Couple, Both 65+, Filing Jointly
Deduction Amount
Standard deduction $32,200
Additional standard deduction for age 65+ ($1,650 × 2) $3,300
New senior deduction (One Big Beautiful Bill, 2025–2028)* $12,000
Total deductions $47,500
*The $6,000-per-person senior deduction phases out once modified adjusted gross income exceeds $150,000 for joint filers.

For someone with $150,000 in income, after deductions you’d be taxed on roughly $102,500, resulting in no more than about $12,000 in federal tax. With taxes this low in retirement, converting to a Roth doesn’t provide much benefit because your traditional IRA withdrawals are already taxed lightly.

When your projected retirement income keeps you in a relatively low tax bracket and when generous standard and senior deductions apply, the traditional IRA can already deliver near tax-free outcomes. In these situations, pre-paying taxes through a Roth conversion offers little advantage. Doing nothing, leaving funds in your traditional IRA and taking distributions strategically, often proves the more tax-efficient and financially prudent approach.

Scenario #3: The Conversion Triggers Hidden Costs (IRMAA, Phaseouts)

Another situation where a Roth conversion can work against you is when you are in your 60s and the conversion triggers hidden costs that you might not be considering. Roth conversions do not only affect your tax bill, although that is often the main focus. They can also influence several other parts of your financial picture.

When you convert to a Roth IRA, the amount converted is treated as taxable income. For individuals in their 60s, that income increase can have several ripple effects. One of the biggest concerns is the Medicare Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, or IRMAA. IRMAA is an additional charge added to your Medicare Part B and Part D premiums if your income exceeds certain thresholds. For 2026, this applies when income is above roughly $109,000 for single filers or $218,000 for married couples filing jointly.

Crossing those limits can raise your Medicare premiums by roughly $96 to $578 per month per person, depending on how far over the line you go—that’s anywhere from about $1,100 to nearly $7,000 per year for each spouse on Medicare. A higher reported income can also cause you to lose certain deductions or credits that phase out at higher income levels, and it can increase the taxable portion of your Social Security benefits.

2026 Medicare IRMAA Surcharges (Based on 2024 Income)
Single filer income Joint filer income Added cost per person / month
$109,000 or less $218,000 or less $0
$109,001 – $137,000 $218,001 – $274,000 $95.70
$137,001 – $171,000 $274,001 – $342,000 $240.40
$171,001 – $205,000 $342,001 – $410,000 $385.00
$205,001 – $499,999 $410,001 – $749,999 $529.60
$500,000 or more $750,000 or more $578.00
Combined Part B and Part D surcharge on top of standard premiums; income is modified adjusted gross income. Source: SSA/CMS 2026 figures.

This issue is especially important for people around age 63 and older. Medicare uses a two-year lookback when determining IRMAA surcharges. That means conversions done at age 63 could affect your Medicare costs when you turn 65.

Key takeaway: If you are approaching Medicare eligibility, consider the potential IRMAA surcharges and their long-term impact as part of your Roth conversion analysis.

Scenario #4: You’re Paying the Taxes from the IRA Itself

The next scenario where a Roth conversion does not make sense is when you plan to pay the taxes for the conversion using money from the IRA itself. This is a major mistake and, in my view, a dealbreaker in every situation.

When doing a Roth conversion, you should always pay the taxes with money from outside the IRA. That way, the full amount of the conversion ends up in the Roth as after-tax dollars that can grow and eventually come out tax-free.

If you do not have outside cash to cover the tax bill, some people make the costly mistake of taking a distribution from their traditional IRA to pay the taxes. This approach creates two problems. First, you will owe income tax on the withdrawal. Second, if you are under age 59½, you will also face a 10% early withdrawal penalty. Both of these reduce the amount that stays invested and growing in the Roth IRA.

For example, say you convert $100,000 while in the 25% tax bracket. You take out $25,000 from the IRA to pay the tax. You will owe another 10% penalty on that $25,000, bringing your total cost to $27,500 in taxes and penalties. That leaves only $75,000 invested in the Roth—and you still have to cover the $2,500 penalty on top of that—which greatly reduces the long-term benefit of the conversion.

Paying the Conversion Tax: Outside Cash vs. the IRA
$100,000 conversion, 25% rate, under 59½ Pay with outside cash Pay from the IRA
Amount that reaches the Roth $100,000 $75,000
Income tax $25,000 $25,000
10% early withdrawal penalty $0 $2,500
Total tax and penalty $25,000 $27,500

If you are in a situation where paying the taxes requires taking money from the IRA itself, it is usually best to pause and reconsider. In nearly every case, a conversion under these circumstances will hurt more than it helps.

Scenario #5: You Plan to Leave the Account to Lower-Tax-Bracket Heirs

A Roth conversion may not make sense when you plan to leave the account to heirs who are in a lower tax bracket. This is where estate planning starts to overlap with your tax and retirement strategy.

If you are in a 24%, 32%, or higher tax bracket, but your children or heirs are only in a 12% or 22% bracket, you may be prepaying taxes at a higher rate than they would pay later. For example, if you convert a $200,000 traditional IRA to a Roth IRA and you are in the 32% bracket, that conversion would cost $64,000 in taxes. If your child later inherits a traditional IRA and withdraws the money while in the 22% bracket, they would pay $44,000 in taxes instead. That is a $20,000 difference, which means the conversion may not be the most efficient move.

Who Pays the Tax on a $200,000 IRA?
You convert now Your heir withdraws later
Tax bracket 32% 22%
Tax owed $64,000 $44,000
Leaving the account as a traditional IRA saves $20,000 in this example.

In some cases, it can actually be better to leave the account as a traditional IRA.

The analysis changes, though, if you are in lower income years in retirement and plan to leave the account to children who are still in their peak earning years. If you are paying 10% to 20% today while your heirs are paying 30% or more, converting to a Roth IRA may make more sense. In that case, you are paying the tax upfront at a lower rate so your heirs can inherit a tax-free asset that can continue to grow.

The facts matter here. Whether it makes sense to convert now or leave the account as-is depends on your tax rate, your heirs’ tax rate, and how the IRA fits into your broader estate plan.

Scenario #6: Your Traditional IRA Is Your Account of Last Resort

The next scenario where a Roth conversion does not make sense is when your traditional IRA is really your account of last resort. In other words, you do not expect to rely on it for retirement income in your 60s or 70s, and you may eventually use it for qualified charitable distributions to causes you care about.

For many people, the traditional IRA is simply the last bucket of money they expect to spend. If that is your situation, and you have other assets or income sources to live on first, converting to Roth may not provide much benefit. By the time you reach your later retirement years, your taxable income may be low enough that withdrawals from the traditional IRA result in little to no tax anyway.

That is why this scenario often comes down to timing and intent. If your plan is to leave the IRA untouched for years and then use it later when your income is lowest, the tax cost of converting today may be higher than the tax cost of leaving it alone. In many cases, the traditional IRA can remain the more efficient choice.

Scenario #7: You Don’t Have a “Gap Year” Window

Another reason a Roth conversion may not make sense is if you do not have a gap year window. One of the best times to convert is during a year when your income is temporarily lower, such as after you stop working but before Social Security or RMDs begin. Those years can create a valuable opportunity to convert at a lower tax rate, sometimes with little or no tax at all.

However, not everyone has that window. You may keep working into your 70s and stay in a high tax bracket, or you may simply never have a year where your income drops enough to make a conversion attractive. In those cases, the clear-cut opportunity to convert at a low tax cost may never appear.

That is why timing matters so much. If you do not have a gap year or another low-income year to work with, a Roth conversion may not deliver the same benefit it would for someone who does.

Scenario #8: State Taxes Work Against You

Finally, the last scenario where a Roth conversion may not make sense is when state taxes work against you. For example, if you live in New York when you do the conversion but plan to retire in Florida and take withdrawals there, state taxes can change the entire equation.

If you are in a high-tax state today, say 8% to 10%, a Roth conversion may look much more expensive than it will later in retirement. For instance, if you are paying 30% in federal taxes and 10% in state taxes today, your total tax cost is 40%. But if you retire in Florida and your future withdrawals are taxed at only 25% federally with no state income tax, then leaving the money in a traditional IRA could actually be the better move.

Convert in New York vs. Withdraw in Florida
Convert today (New York) Withdraw later (Florida)
Federal tax rate 30% 25%
State tax rate 10% 0%
Total tax rate 40% 25%

In that case, you would be paying 40% today to convert to Roth instead of paying 25% later on traditional withdrawals. That is a much bigger tax bill upfront, so the conversion does not make sense. Always factor in where you live now versus where you expect to live in retirement, because state taxes can significantly change the outcome.

The Big Picture: Why It Always Depends

Now that we have covered the 8 scenarios where a Roth conversion may not make sense, it is worth stepping back to look at the bigger picture. Whether a Roth conversion is the right move is always situational.

It depends on your current income, your expected future income, the amount you want to convert, your tax bracket today versus later in retirement, the state you live in now versus the state you may live in later, and your long-term legacy goals. Are you planning to spend down this account in retirement, or are you trying to preserve it for children or other heirs?

One of the biggest mistakes people make is converting without running the numbers first. Roth accounts are powerful, but they are not always the right tool. A traditional IRA to Roth IRA conversion only makes sense when the math supports it. Do not leave your decision to guesswork; crunch the numbers specific to your situation first.

If you would like help determining whether a Roth conversion makes sense in your situation or building a more tax-efficient retirement strategy, my team at KKOS Lawyers works with investors and business owners across the country. You can book a free call using the link below, and we will help you map out the smartest approach based on your numbers.

FREE STRATEGY CALL

Find out whether a Roth conversion actually makes sense for your numbers.

Contact Us – KKOS Lawyers

The Roth IRA 5-Year Rule Everyone Gets Wrong (It’s Actually Two Clocks)

Your Roth IRA is only tax-free if you satisfy two separate five-year rules—each running on its own clock. Get either one wrong, and what you thought was a tax-free withdrawal can land on your 1040 as ordinary income, plus potential penalties.

These rules affect more investors than you might expect: anyone with multiple Roth IRAs, anyone who has changed custodians, backdoor Roth contributors, savers executing gap-year conversion strategies before retirement, and those who opened their first Roth IRA later in life and assumed age 59½ made everything automatically tax-free.

The key question is simple but critical: which clock applies to which dollars? Every Roth IRA can hold three types of money: contributions, conversions, and earnings. The two five-year rules treat each type differently. Some funds are immediately accessible, some unlock on a schedule, and some remain conditional until a specific date.

The short version:

RULE 1

The Account Clock

You must have a Roth IRA open for five years before earnings can be withdrawn tax-free. This clock starts on January 1 of the tax year of your first Roth contribution (or conversion, if earlier) and applies collectively to all your Roth IRAs. It never resets when you switch custodians or open additional Roth accounts.

RULE 2

The Conversion Clock

Each Roth conversion has its own five-year clock. This rule does not affect whether the conversion itself is taxed—you already paid that—but it can shield you from the 10% early-withdrawal penalty if you take converted funds out before age 59½.

The costly mistake: Most costly mistakes come from applying the right rule to the wrong dollars. Misstep on $50,000 of earnings, and you could hand the IRS $12,000 in taxes on growth that should have been yours, tax-free, forever.

Clock #1 — The Account Clock (This One Applies to Everyone)

For your Roth IRA earnings to come out completely tax-free, you must satisfy two conditions:

  • 1Be at least age 59½ (or meet another qualifying exception), and
  • 2Have satisfied the Roth IRA five-year rule

The five-year clock starts on January 1 of the tax year in which you made your first Roth IRA contribution—whether that contribution was to a traditional Roth IRA or a Roth conversion IRA. Once that clock starts, it applies to all your Roth IRAs and never resets.

If you make a Roth contribution in April 2027 but designate it for the 2026 tax year, the five-year clock is treated as starting on January 1, 2026. In that case, you reach the five-year mark in under four calendar years.

A common misconception is that each Roth IRA has its own five-year timer. It doesn’t. You get one lifetime clock tied to your first Roth contribution. Switching custodians, rolling assets, or opening additional Roth IRAs does not restart the five-year period; the clock follows you.

EXAMPLE: SWITCHING CUSTODIANS

You opened a Roth IRA at Fidelity, held it for three years, then transferred everything to Directed IRA and bought real estate inside the Roth IRA. Your clock kept running. You now have six years on the same clock.

EXAMPLE: OPENING YOUR FIRST ROTH IRA LATE IN LIFE

You open your first Roth IRA at 58 and want to withdraw at 60. At 60, you’re past the 59½ threshold, so the 10% early-withdrawal penalty no longer applies—but earnings remain taxable until the five-year rule is satisfied. In this scenario, contributions can be withdrawn tax- and penalty-free at 60, but any earnings taken before age 63 are taxable. Once the five-year clock is met at 63, qualified distributions—including earnings—become entirely tax-free.

Age 58

First Roth IRA opened. The account clock starts.

Age 59½

The 10% penalty no longer applies, but earnings are still taxable.

Age 63

Five-year clock met. Earnings come out tax-free.

Age 59½ eliminates the penalty, not the tax on earnings. Tax-free treatment on earnings requires both (1) being at least 59½ (or meeting another qualifying condition) and (2) satisfying the five-year account clock. Once any Roth IRA has been open for five years—counting transfers and custodian changes—earnings can be withdrawn tax-free as soon as the age or other qualifying condition is met.

FREE SELF-DIRECTED IRA GUIDE

Learn how a self-directed Roth IRA can invest in real estate, private funds, and other alternative assets you actually understand.

Get the Free Self-Directed IRA Guide

Clock #2 — The Conversion Clock (Situational, and the One People Mess Up)

Every Roth conversion carries its own five-year clock, starting January 1 of the conversion year. This rule exists to prevent investors from using conversions as a loophole to sidestep the 10% early-withdrawal penalty. You pay income tax on the conversion in the year it occurs, but that does not automatically make the converted funds penalty-free if withdrawn immediately.

The rule is narrow but important: if you withdraw converted Roth dollars within five years and you’re under 59½, the IRS imposes a 10% early-withdrawal penalty on the amount taken. Wait out the full five years, and those converted dollars behave like regular Roth contributions which are withdrawable at any age, tax- and penalty-free. Earnings, however, remain subject to Rule 1 (the account clock) and the age 59½ requirement.

EXAMPLE: EARLY ACCESS AFTER CONVERSION

At 45, you have $100,000 in a Roth IRA and $100,000 in a traditional IRA. You convert the entire traditional IRA to Roth, pay the tax in 2026, and let the account grow. By age 51, the five-year conversion clock has run its course, and the converted funds have grown to $150,000. You can withdraw the $100,000 of converted principal tax- and penalty-free at 51. The $50,000 of earnings, however, remains off-limits without tax and penalty until you satisfy Rule 1 and reach 59½. Withdrawing earnings early could trigger both income tax and a 10% penalty—potentially costing $17,000 on a $50,000 distribution.

$100,000

Converted principal: tax- and penalty-free at 51

$50,000

Earnings: taking them early could cost about $17,000 in tax and penalty

EXAMPLE: BACKDOOR ROTH AND MULTIPLE CLOCKS

For backdoor Roth IRA users, each annual conversion starts its own five-year timer. If you’re 50 and contribute $7,500 annually to a non-deductible traditional IRA, then convert to Roth each year, every conversion has a separate timeline. The 2026 conversion unlocks in 2031, the 2027 conversion in 2032, and so on. After six years of this strategy, you don’t have a single locked Roth balance; you have a rolling conveyor belt of penalty-free principal, with a new tranche becoming available each January 1.

Backdoor Roth: Each Conversion Unlocks on Its Own Date
Year converted Amount Penalty-free from
2026 $7,500 Jan. 1, 2031
2027 $7,500 Jan. 1, 2032
2028 $7,500 Jan. 1, 2033
2029 $7,500 Jan. 1, 2034
2030 $7,500 Jan. 1, 2035
2031 $7,500 Jan. 1, 2036
Assumes $7,500 converted each year. The conversion clock only matters before age 59½; earnings still follow the account clock.

EXAMPLE: THE “SHUTOFF SWITCH” AT 59½

The conversion five-year rule only guards against the 10% early-withdrawal penalty, which disappears at 59½. After that age, the rule no longer matters. A 62-year-old executing a gap-year conversion strategy can convert traditional IRA funds to Roth at 62 and withdraw those converted dollars at 63 without penalty.

However, Rule 1—the account five-year clock—still applies. If this investor opened their first Roth IRA at 60 and has never held one before, earnings cannot be withdrawn tax-free until age 65, when the five-year account requirement is satisfied. Converted principal remains accessible without penalty, but growth and earnings must wait.

For anyone new to Roth IRAs after 59½, the key is to track both clocks: the conversion timers for penalty avoidance before 59½, and the single lifetime account clock for tax-free treatment of earnings.

The Two Roth Clocks at a Glance

CLOCK #1

The Account Clock

HOW MANY

One lifetime clock

STARTS

Jan. 1 of the tax year of your first Roth IRA contribution or conversion

APPLIES TO

All your Roth IRAs

DETERMINES

When earnings can become tax-free

RESETS?

Never, even when you change custodians or open another Roth IRA

THINK

Tax-free earnings

CLOCK #2

The Conversion Clock

HOW MANY

A new clock for each conversion

STARTS

Jan. 1 of the year of each conversion

APPLIES TO

Each conversion separately

DETERMINES

Whether converted dollars can be withdrawn without the 10% early-withdrawal penalty before age 59½

RESETS?

Each conversion starts another clock

THINK

Penalty-free converted principal

The Machinery That Makes This Navigable — Ordering Rules

When Congress created Roth IRAs, it built in a powerful safeguard: a strict ordering rule for withdrawals. Every distribution comes out in a specific sequence—contributions first, then conversions, then earnings. This order matters because each bucket carries different tax and penalty treatment. The rules ensure you access the safest dollars first and only reach the most restricted funds last.

The Three Buckets, in Order

1

ALWAYS COME OUT FIRST

Regular Roth Contributions

These are tax- and penalty-free at any age, with no five-year waiting period. If you withdraw at 50, you’re pulling contributions first—no clocks to track, no forms to justify.

2

COME OUT SECOND

Converted Amounts

Each conversion has its own five-year clock (Clock #2). Once that period has passed, the converted principal can be withdrawn tax- and penalty-free, even before age 59½. If the clock hasn’t run, a 10% penalty may apply if you’re under 59½.

3

ALWAYS COME OUT LAST

Earnings and Growth

This is the most restricted bucket. To withdraw earnings tax- and penalty-free, you must satisfy both five-year rules and be at least 59½ (or meet another qualifying condition). The IRS won’t let you touch earnings until contributions and conversions are exhausted.

This ordering is automatic—you don’t choose which dollars come out. The IRS mandates the sequence that minimizes your tax burden. You cannot accidentally withdraw taxable earnings while untaxed contributions or seasoned conversions remain in the account.

EXAMPLE: KNOW WHICH DOLLARS YOU CAN TOUCH

Suppose your Roth IRA holds $200,000:

  • $80,000 in regular contributions
  • $70,000 from a 2019 Roth conversion
  • $50,000 in earnings and growth

You can withdraw $150,000 today with zero tax or penalty, even if you’re under 59½:

  • The $80,000 in contributions is always accessible
  • The $70,000 conversion is seasoned—its five-year clock ended in 2024
  • Only the $50,000 in earnings remains conditional. The IRS requires you to exhaust the $150,000 first before any earnings can be distributed

Your custodian’s statements show your account balance, but not the breakdown by bucket. To track contributions, conversions, and distributions, you’ll use IRS Form 8606, which reports Roth IRA activity—including conversions and distributions—on your federal tax return. This form ensures the IRS knows which dollars you’ve withdrawn and whether any portion is taxable or subject to penalty.

Understanding these three buckets—and the ordering rule that governs them—gives you clarity on what you can access today, what requires waiting, and how to avoid unnecessary taxes and penalties.

Infographic: Roth IRA withdrawal order. Contributions come out first, conversions second, earnings last, and which five-year clock applies to each
Infographic: Roth IRA withdrawal order. Contributions come out first, conversions second, earnings last, and which five-year clock applies to each

When Neither Rule Matters (So You Don’t Overthink It)

Most Roth IRA owners never need to stress over the two five-year clocks. In many common situations, the rules are already satisfied—or simply don’t apply.

You can ignore the clocks if:

  • ✓You’re withdrawing regular Roth contributions (not conversions). These come out first, tax- and penalty-free, at any age, for any reason
  • ✓You’re 59½ or older and have held a Roth IRA for at least five years. Both clocks are effectively dead: the conversion clock only guards the 10% early-withdrawal penalty (which no longer exists after 59½), and the account clock is already met, so earnings are tax-free

If you’re 45 and don’t plan to touch your Roth until 60, these rules are largely trivial. Contribute, invest, and let compounding work. By retirement, both five-year requirements will be long satisfied, and your Roth will function as the tax-free ATM it was designed to be.

Where mistakes happen:

  • !Early withdrawal of converted funds: You convert to Roth, then pull those dollars out before five years have passed while under 59½—triggering a 10% penalty on the amount taken
  • !Late starters: You open your first Roth IRA at 58, assume everything is tax-free at 59½, and withdraw earnings early. In reality, earnings remain taxable until the account itself has existed for five years—meaning tax-free treatment doesn’t begin until age 63 in this scenario

If neither situation describes you, relax. Your Roth IRA’s tax-free growth is intact. Wait until after 59½ and once the five-year account clock is met, and you’ll enjoy the full benefit: tax-free income in retirement, exactly as Congress intended.

What This All Really Comes Down To

Here’s what the 5-year Roth rule really comes down to: it isn’t one rule, and it isn’t simply about waiting five years.

The key is knowing which Roth dollars you’re dealing with. The tax code effectively treats your Roth IRA as three separate buckets: contributions, conversions, and earnings. Those buckets don’t all follow the same rules. Add in two different five-year clocks, and it’s easy to see where the confusion starts.

In fact, the people most likely to make a costly mistake aren’t necessarily those who have never heard of the five-year rule. They’re the people who know about it—but apply the wrong five-year rule to the wrong bucket of money.

That distinction becomes especially important if you have multiple Roth IRAs, have switched custodians, regularly make backdoor Roth contributions, have completed Roth conversions, or opened your first Roth later in life. Before taking money out, make sure you know which bucket the distribution is coming from and which clock—if any—actually applies.

And remember, a Roth IRA doesn’t have to be limited to publicly traded stocks and mutual funds. A self-directed Roth IRA can hold assets such as real estate, private funds, private businesses, cryptocurrency, and more. At Directed IRA, we help investors establish and administer self-directed retirement accounts. If you want to explore whether a self-directed Roth IRA fits your strategy, book a free 15-minute call with our team here.

FREE 15-MINUTE CALL

See whether a self-directed Roth IRA fits your strategy, from real estate to private funds.

Book a Call with Directed IRA

Back Door Roth IRA Rules and Steps

Roth IRAs can be established and funded for high-income earners by using what is known as the “back door” Roth IRA contribution method. Many high-income earners believe that they can’t contribute to a Roth IRA because they make too much money and/or because they participate in a company 401k plan. Fortunately, this thinking is wrong. While direct contributions to a Roth IRA are limited for taxpayers with income in excess of $153,000 ($242,000 for married taxpayers, 2026), those whose income exceeds these amounts may make annual contributions to a non-deductible traditional IRA and then convert those amounts over to a Roth IRA.

Infographic: how the back door Roth IRA works. Contribute to a non-deductible traditional IRA, convert it to a Roth IRA, and grow tax-free, plus how existing traditional IRAs make the conversion taxable and two 401(k) workarounds
Infographic: how the back door Roth IRA works. Contribute to a non-deductible traditional IRA, convert it to a Roth IRA, and grow tax-free, plus how existing traditional IRAs make the conversion taxable and two 401(k) workarounds

Examples

Here are a few examples of earners who can establish and fund a Roth IRA.

  1. 1I’m a high-income earner and work for a company that offers a company 401(k) plan. I contribute the maximum amount to that plan each year. Can I establish and fund a Roth IRA?
    Yes, even though you are high-income and even though you participate in a company 401(k) plan, you can establish and fund a Roth IRA.
  2. 2I’m self-employed and earn over $242,000 a year; can I have a Roth IRA? Isn’t my income too high? Yes, you can contribute to a Roth IRA despite having an income that exceeds the Roth IRA income contribution limits of $242,000 for married taxpayers and $153,000 for single taxpayers

The Process

The strategy used by high-income earners to make Roth IRA contributions involves the making of non-deductible contributions to a traditional IRA and then converting those funds in the non-deductible traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. This is oftentimes referred to as a “back door” Roth IRA. In the end, you don’t get a tax deduction in the amounts contributed, but the funds are held in a Roth IRA and grow, then come out tax-free upon retirement (just like a Roth IRA). Here’s how it works.

Step 1: Fund a new non-deductible traditional IRA

This IRA is “non-deductible” because high-income earners who participate in a company retirement plan (or who have a spouse who does) can’t also make “deductible” contributions to an IRA. The account can, however, be funded by non-deductible amounts up to the IRA annual contribution amounts of $7,500. The non-deductible contributions mean you don’t get a tax deduction on the amounts contributed to the traditional IRA. You don’t have to worry about having non-deductible contributions as you’re converting to a Roth IRA, so you don’t want a deduction for the funds contributed. If you did get a deduction for the contribution, you’d have to pay taxes on the amounts later converted to Roth. You’ll need to file IRS form 8606 for the tax year in which you make non-deductible IRA contributions. The form can be found here.

If you’re a high-income earner and you don’t have a company-based retirement plan (or a spouse with one), then you simply establish a standard deductible traditional IRA, as there is no high-income contribution limitation on traditional IRAs when you don’t participate in a company plan.

Step 2: Convert the non-deductible traditional IRA funds to a Roth IRA

In 2010, the limitations on Roth IRA conversions, which previously restricted Roth IRA conversions for high-income earners, were removed. As a result, since 2010 all taxpayers are able to convert traditional IRA funds to Roth IRAs. It was in 2010 that this back door Roth IRA contribution strategy was first utilized, as it relied on the ability to convert funds from traditional to Roth. It has been used by thousands of Americans since.

If you have other existing traditional IRAs, then the tax treatment of your conversion to Roth becomes a little more complicated, as you must take into account those existing IRA funds when undertaking a conversion (including SEPs and SIMPLE IRAs). If the only IRA you have is the non-deductible IRA, then the conversion is easy because you convert the entire non-deductible IRA amount over to Roth with no tax on the conversion. Remember, you didn’t get a deduction into the non-deductible traditional IRA so there is no tax to apply on conversions. On the other hand, if you have an existing IRA with say $95,000 in it and you have $5,000 in non-deductible traditional IRA contributions in another account that you wish to convert to Roth, then the IRS requires you to convert over your IRA funds in equal parts deductible (the $95K bucket) and non-deductible amounts (the new $5K) based on the money you have in all traditional IRAs. So, if you wanted to convert $10,000, then you’d have to convert $9,500 (95%) of your deductible bucket, which portion of conversion is subject to tax, and $500 of your non-deductible bucket, which isn’t subject to tax once converted. Consequently, the “back door” Roth IRA isn’t well suited when you have existing traditional IRAs that contain deductible contributions and earnings from those sums.

There are two workarounds to this Roth IRA conversion problem and both revolve around moving the existing traditional IRA funds into a 401(k) or other employer-based plans. Employer plan funds are not considered when determining what portions of the traditional IRAs are subject to tax on conversion (the deductible AND the non-deductible). If you participate in an existing company 401(k) plan, then you may roll over your traditional IRA funds into that 401(k) plan. Most 401(k) plans allow for this rollover from IRA to 401(k) so long as you are still employed by that company. If you are self-employed, you may establish a solo or owner-only 401(k) plan and you can rollover your traditional IRA dollars into this 401(k). In the end though, if you can’t roll out existing traditional IRA funds into a 401(k), then the “back door” Roth IRA is going to cause some tax repercussions, as you also have to convert a portion of the existing traditional IRA funds, which will cause taxes upon conversion. Taxes on conversion aren’t “the end of the world” though as all of the money that comes out of that traditional IRA would be subject to tax at some point in time. The only issue is it causes a big tax bill initially, so careful planning must be taken.

The bottom line is that Roth IRAs can be established and funded by high-income earners. Don’t consider yourself “left out” on one of the greatest tax strategies offered to Americans: the Roth IRA.

FREE SELF-DIRECTED IRA GUIDE

Learn how a self-directed Roth IRA can invest in real estate, private companies, notes, and more, and keep the growth tax-free.

Get the Free Self-Directed IRA Guide

Prefer to talk it through? Book a call with a Directed IRA specialist

Mat Sorensen

Mat has been at the forefront of the self-directed IRA industry since 2006. He is the CEO of Directed IRA & Directed Trust Company where they handle all types of self-directed accounts (IRAs, Roth IRAs, HSAs, Coverdell ESA, Solo Ks, and Custodial Accounts) which are typically invested into real estate, private company/private equity, IRA/LLCs, notes, precious metals, and cryptocurrency. Mat is also a partner at KKOS Lawyers and serves clients nationwide from its Phoenix, AZ office.

He is published regularly on retirement, tax, and business topics, and is a VIP Contributor at Entrepreneur.com. Mat is the best-selling author of the most widely used book in the self-directed IRA industry, The Self-Directed IRA Handbook: An Authoritative Guide for Self-Directed Retirement Plan Investors and Their Advisors.

Seller Financed Deals and Installment Sales

Seller financed deals can be a win-win strategy for buyers and sellers of real estate or businesses. Seller financing means the seller of the asset, whether a business or property, agrees to take payments over time for the purchase price and as a result the seller is financing the sale of the asset to the buyer. This has many benefits for a seller as it only opens up more buyers and hopefully a higher sales price but it also includes a tax incentive to the seller who will get to consider the sale of the asset as an installment sale. An installment sale allows the seller to defer recognition of the gain until the time the payments and the resulting gain are received.

Infographic: how an installment sale taxes each seller-financed payment using the gross profit percentage, a worked example, the benefits and drawbacks for the seller, and the documents that protect the sale
Infographic: how an installment sale taxes each seller-financed payment using the gross profit percentage, a worked example, the benefits and drawbacks for the seller, and the documents that protect the sale

How an Installment Sale Is Taxed

In an installment sale, you report your gain on the sale of asset only as it is received. Each payment will be partially non-taxable as it represents a return of basis (what you invested into the asset) and the taxable part which is your profit (gain, appreciation). So, when you sell an asset on an installment sale you do not pay all of the taxes in the year you sell the asset because you have not fully received payment. Instead, you pay taxes only as you receive payment. To correctly report the taxes, you need to determine what portion of each installment payment is a return of basis versus profit.

Calculating the Taxable Portion of Each Payment

To do this, you divide your gross profit (selling price minus basis) by the contract price.

EXAMPLE

For example, say you purchased a property for $100,000 and later sell it for $400,000 under seller financed terms. Since you purchased the property for $100,000, you have a basis of $100,000 (you would also adjust the basis for improvements, depreciation, and other factors) and we are assuming here a contract sale price is $400,000. This gives you a gross profit of $300,000 (selling price minus basis). You then divide your gross profit of $300,000 by the $400,000 contract sale price, which equals 75%. You then take this 75% and apply it to each payment to determine which portion of the payment is taxable. This makes sense because each payment you receive, in this example, equally consists of a return of your basis, which is not taxable, and a payment towards the gross profit, which is taxable. To finish this example at 75%, if the annual payments totaled $40K, you’d have $30K that is taxable and $10K that is not taxable. If there is interest charged on the amount due that interest portion is also taxable as it is received.

$300,000

Gross profit ($400,000 sale price minus $100,000 basis)

75%

Of each payment is taxable

$30K of $40K

Annual payments that are taxable

Benefits and Drawbacks for the Seller

The tax benefit of the installment sale is that you only take a portion of the gain into income each year over time. This gives the advantage of deferring taxes over time and can also keep you in a lower tax bracket on your other income. The major disadvantage is that you do not obtain the sale proceeds immediately and as a result you cannot invest them elsewhere. To counter this, most sellers will charge the buyer interest on the seller financed balance that is due, say 7-10%, to offset the inability to invest the funds immediately.

As a seller, you will want to have a properly drafted promissory note as well as a security document that is secured against the asset being sold (e.g. mortgage/deed of trust recorded against the property). Make sure you are collaborating with experienced professionals when selling assets with seller-financing as there are tax considerations and legal protections you want to ensure are being considered in the structuring and documents.

Stuck With a 401K Loan and Leaving Your Job

Have you taken a loan from your employer 401(k) plan and plan on leaving? Unfortunately, most company plans will require you to repay the loan within 60 days, or they will distribute the amount outstanding on the loan from your 401(k) account. It’s one of the ways they try to keep their employees from leaving. “Don’t leave or we’ll distribute your 401(k) loan that you took from your money in your 401(k) account.”

Infographic: leaving your job with a 401(k) loan. Repay the outstanding loan amount to an IRA by your tax return deadline, including extensions, to avoid taxes and penalties
Infographic: leaving your job with a 401(k) loan. Repay the outstanding loan amount to an IRA by your tax return deadline, including extensions, to avoid taxes and penalties

How to Buy Yourself More Time & Avoid the Distribution

The good news is that following the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) you now have the option to re-pay the loan to an IRA to avoid the distribution and you have until your personal tax return deadline of the following year (including extensions) to contribute that re-payment amount to an IRA. By re-paying the amount outstanding on the loan to an IRA, you will avoid taxes and penalties that would otherwise arise from distribution of a participant 401(k) loan.

How It Works In Practice

EXAMPLE

Let’s say you left employment from your employer in February 2026 and that you had a 401(k) loan that was distributed by your employer’s plan following your termination of employment. You will have until October 15th of 2027 (if you extend your personal return, 6 month extension from April 15th) to make re-payment of the amount that was outstanding on the loan to an IRA. These funds are then treated as a rollover to your IRA from the 401(k) plan and your distribution and 1099-R will be reported on your federal tax return as a rollover and will not be subject to tax and penalty. While it’s not perfect it’s far greater time than was previously allowed. Traditionally, you had 30 or 60 days at most to make re-payment.

Limitations

The ability to rollover an outstanding 401(k) loan amount to an IRA is only available when you have left an employer (for any reason). It does not apply in instances where you are still employed and have simply failed to re-pay the loan or to make timely payments.

FREE ROLLOVER GUIDE

Learn how to move an old 401(k) or IRA into a self-directed IRA, tax-free.

Get the Free Transfers & Rollovers Guide

Prefer to talk it through? Book a call with a Directed IRA specialist

Mat Sorensen

Mat has been at the forefront of the self-directed IRA industry since 2006. He is the CEO of Directed IRA & Directed Trust Company where they handle all types of self-directed accounts (IRAs, Roth IRAs, HSAs, Coverdell ESA, Solo Ks, and Custodial Accounts) which are typically invested into real estate, private company/private equity, IRA/LLCs, notes, precious metals, and cryptocurrency. Mat is also a partner at KKOS Lawyers and serves clients nationwide from its Phoenix, AZ office.

He is published regularly on retirement, tax, and business topics, and is a VIP Contributor at Entrepreneur.com. Mat is the best-selling author of the most widely used book in the self-directed IRA industry, The Self-Directed IRA Handbook: An Authoritative Guide for Self-Directed Retirement Plan Investors and Their Advisors.